Bells
Animal Crossing
Getting a Mythic Prankster Nightmare Dungeon Sigil in Diablo 4 Season 11 is not about luck alone — it’s about how many rolls you can realistically force in a short amount of time. In this D4 Season 11 Mythic Prankster Sigil farm guide, we'll break down the best way to get them fast.

This method is not a guarantee, but it is currently one of the highest-efficiency ways to maximize your chances of finding a Mythic Prankster Nightmare Dungeon Sigil by massively increasing the number of sigils you see per hour. The core idea is simple, convert boss materials into Outdoor Asmodan chests → flood yourself with Nightmare Sigils → brute-force the Prankster roll.
In simple terms, Mythic Prankster is a special modifier that can appear on Nightmare Dungeon sigils. When active, it guarantees the presence of a unique treasure goblin inside the dungeon — Fancy Old Fedric. This goblin is not a normal loot pinata. Killing him is what makes Mythic Prankster so powerful.
When Fancy Old Fedric is defeated under a Mythic Prankster sigil, the dungeon can shower your entire party with:
Multiple D4 Mythic Unique items
A Resplendent Spark
High-tier Legendary Runes
Additional endgame loot, scaled to Torment 4
Difficulty - Torment 4 (mandatory). Seasonal Essences (VERY IMPORTANT) - You must have both at max rank (Rank 5).
Essence of Hellfire
Essence of Sin
Correct Setup:
General farming:
Hellfire → Purified slot
Sin → Corrupted slot
Outdoor Asmodan fight: Swap → Sin in Purified, Hellfire in Corrupted. This directly affects Nightmare Sigil drops from chests.
Farm ~200 Living Steel from Helltide chests. This is the only manual Living Steel farm you need. The loop becomes self-sustaining afterward.
Spend Living Steel to open Grigo chests. Cost: 12 Living Steel per chest.
Rewards:
Shards of Agony
Stygian Stones
Chance for Bile ambush (huge bonus)
Why Grigo? Because:
Shards of Agony → Duriel
Duriel → Corrupted Horns
Corrupted Horns → Outdoor Asmodan chests
3 Shards of Agony = 1 Duriel chest. Each chest gives 3 Corrupted Horns of Duriel. From ~16 shards: ≈ 15 Corrupted Horns.
South of Zarbinzet
Before fighting:
Swap Essences
Sin → Purified
Hellfire → Corrupted
Chest Costs
5 Corrupted Horns per Duriel chest
15 Horns = 3 chest opens
What You Get
Each chest can drop: ~40 Living Steel or ~30 Exquisite Blood. Large batches of Nightmare Dungeon Sigils ← THIS IS THE POINT
Using materials gained:
Boss Targets
Grigo → More Agony + Stygian Stones
Lord Zir (Exquisite Blood) → Pin Cushion Dolls
Bile (Betrayer’s Husks) → Corrupted Eyes
Conversions
Pin Cushion Dolls → Andariel Cloth
Betrayer’s Husks → Corrupted Eyes of Bile
Stygian Stones → Shards of Agony (Always do this)
Do NOT waste Stygian Stones on anything else.
Return to Outdoor Asmodan and open:
Duriel chests (Horns)
Andariel chests (Cloth)
Bile chests (Eyes)
With Essence of Sin in Purified slot. This is where you see hundreds of Nightmare Sigils and mass-roll for Mythic Prankster.
Pick up one inventory of sigils. Check each for Mythic Prankster affix. Drop checked sigils away from the chest. DO NOT teleport to town immediately. You can lose un-checked sigils. Once checked Salvage at Occultist → Sigil Powder.
Use Sigil Powder at the Occultist. Craft Nightmare Dungeon Sigils. Check each batch. Salvage and repeat if needed. This adds dozens more rolls per cycle.
Extra Optimizations
World Boss > Everything. Always do them if up. Free Nightmare Sigils.
Goblin Events
Keep Treasure Breach sigils. Legendary Sigils can be saved or salvaged based on preference.
Community average: ~1 Mythic Prankster per ~500 sigils. This method lets you check hundreds of sigils in ~1–2 hours. Example result: Mythic Prankster obtained in ~1.5 hours (lucky, but realistic).